Which Dog Subscription Box Matches Your Pup’s Personality? Take the Quick Quiz to Get Your Match!
If you’ve ever wondered which dog subscription box fits your pup’s personality best, this quick and fun dog subscription box quiz will help you sniff out the perfect monthly box—whether your dog’s a destroyer, diva, foodie, or cuddle bug.
Around our house, toys don’t last long. That became clear about two years ago when I handed Carly a brand-new plush toy. I barely had time to sit back down before the squeaker was ripped out, and stuffing was scattered across the floor like confetti.
We laughed (sort of), cleaned up the fluff (again), and added yet another casualty to the pile of well-meaning toys that just didn’t stand a chance.
So I did what any savvy dog parent would do: I went searching for the perfect subscription box. Not just something cute, but something Carly-proof. I was on a realistic, slightly desperate mission to find a toy that might last longer than a minute in my house. I even timed her once—2.7 seconds from excited squeal to total toy obliteration. That poor turtle never stood a chance.
But along the way, I realized something important: just like people, dogs have personalities. Big ones. Quirky ones. Slightly dramatic ones. (Carly included.) Some dogs want fashion. Some want snacks. Carly? She wants structural integrity. So yeah—subscription boxes? Around here, they’re kind of a big deal.
Not sure which subscription box is best for your dog? Take the dog subscription box quiz now and find your pup’s perfect match! [Start the Quiz ↓]
And the best part? Now, she knows when a box is for her. She literally cries—actual happy whines—when one gets dropped on the porch. We’re talking full-body tail wags and nose pressed to the door. At this point, any box that shows up gets her hopes up—even if it’s just my Amazon order of lightbulbs and shampoo. (Sorry, girl.)
Take the Dog Subscription Box Quiz
When it comes to subscription boxes, one-size-fits-all just doesn’t cut it. That’s where curated monthly deliveries come in—a surprise box of joy that actually matches your dog’s vibe. So whether you’ve got a glam queen, a couch potato, a treat snob, a budding Einstein, or a determined destroyer like mine—there’s a box out there built just for them.
1. The Toy Destroyer
Best Box: BarkBox Super Chewer
Your dog doesn’t just play with toys—they challenge them to a duel and always win. Plush toys? Gone in 60 seconds. Squeakers? Surgically removed like a seasoned vet. If your pup treats every new toy like it’s their arch-nemesis, you need the heavy-duty stuff. That’s why, based on your dog subscription box quiz result, the Super Chewer is a top pick.
Why Super Chewer?
The Bark Box Super Chewer was made for the tough customer. Each month brings ultra-durable toys designed to outlast even the most relentless chompers, along with all-natural treats and chews to keep their jaws busy. It’s the chew toy version of CrossFit.
Savvy Dog Mom Tip: You can customize based on allergies or preferences. Because even tough dogs have sensitive tummies. Plans start at just $25 per month—with options to subscribe for 1, 6, or 12 months.
2. The Foodie with Standards
Best Box: The Farmer’s Dog Meal Plan (or Ollie for variety)
We all know the type: your dog sniffs a treat and looks at you like you just offered them a gas station hot dog. Some dogs just know what they like—and it’s fresh, real, human-grade food, thank you very much. Based on your dog subscription box quiz result, your pup’s refined palate deserves nothing less than fresh, real food—this one’s a top-tier match.
Why Farmer’s Dog or Ollie?
These aren’t traditional treat-and-toy boxes, but if your pup lives for dinnertime (and expects it to be Michelin-star quality), the Farmer’s Dog is the monthly subscription they deserve. You’ll get perfectly portioned meals made from real ingredients—delivered frozen and ready to thaw. Spoiled? Absolutely. But in the healthiest way possible.
Savvy Dog Mom Tip: Great for picky eaters, dogs with allergies, or anyone whose dog eats better than they do. Subscription plans start at $75 per month.
3. The Brainiac
Best Box: PupBox
This is for the pup who needs mental stimulation like most dogs need belly rubs. They’re smart, sneaky, and get bored faster than you can say, “Wanna go outside?” Give them too much downtime, and they’ll find their entertainment—usually at your expense. If your dog subscription box quiz result came back “Brainiac,” PupBox is the monthly challenge your clever pup needs to stay busy—and out of trouble.
Why PupBox?
PupBox grows with your dog, offering developmental toys, training treats, and helpful guides tailored to your pup’s age and stage.
Savvy Dog Mom Tip: You’ll feel like a genius for keeping your genius dog occupied. PupBox starts at $39 per month, but loyal pups (and their humans) save big—annual plans drop the price to just $22 per month.
4. The Glam Pup
Best Box: Dapper Dog Box
Some dogs roll in mud. Yours prefers a spa day. This is the pup whose Instagram game is strong, whose collar matches your outfit, and who somehow manages to pose perfectly in every photo. Treats are nice—but accessories? That’s their love language.
Why Dapper Dog Box?
Your quiz result says your pup is basically the Paris Hilton of the dog park. Dapper Dog Box is where glam meets goodies. Every month, Dapper Dog Box will send your style-forward pup high-quality treats, two toys, and—most importantly—a fashion-forward bandana that says, “I woke up like this.” It’s a lifestyle.
Savvy Dog Mom Tip: You can customize for allergies and for vibe. Talk about curated. Plans starts at $20 per month.
5. The Adventure Hound
Best Box: Wild One
Your dog hears the leash jingle and goes full send. Hiking trails? Let’s go. Beach day? Already in the car. This is the pup who thrives in the great outdoors and needs gear, treats, and toys that can keep up with their go-go-go energy. Based on your dog subscription box quiz result, you’ve got a trailblazer on your hands—Wild One is built for the pup who never sits still.
Why Wild One or Goody Box?
Wild One isn’t a traditional subscription, but you can create your own adventure kit with durable leashes, collapsible bowls, and treat pouches for the trail.
Savvy Dog Mom Tip: Add a custom ID tag to your box just in case your explorer gets a little too curious on a hike. Wild One plans start at $40 per month.
6. The Sensitive Soul
Best Box: RescueBox
Some dogs are just more tender-hearted. Maybe they came from a tough beginning or were just naturally cautious. These pups thrive on calm routines, gentle encouragement, and extra love. If your dog leans on you for comfort, they deserve a box that matches that energy. If your dog subscription box quiz result was “Sensitive Soul,” RescueBox offers the care, calm, and comfort your pup deserves.
Why RescueBox?
RescueBox delivers thoughtful toys and treats, but its mission sets it apart. With every box shipped, donations are made to help shelter animals in need—food, vaccines, and supplies. It’s a box with a heart for dogs who understand the value of safety and second chances.
Savvy Dog Mom Tip: You’re giving your dog something special and supporting other dogs that are still waiting for their person. Win-win. RescueBox plans start at $35 per month.
7. Savvy Dog Mom-Approved
The Box Carly Can’t Get Enough Of: Bullymake
Let’s be honest—Carly doesn’t just nibble her toys; she obliterates them. We’ve tested more brands than I can count, but the one that consistently passes the Carly durability test is Bullymake.
From hot pink lips to a blue seahorse to a pretend cell phone, the toys in her Bullymake boxes have lasted. And not in a “sitting untouched in the corner” way—these toys have been tugged, chomped, flung, and fiercely loved. Some are still going strong months later, which, if you know Carly, is saying something.
Why Bullymake Wins:
Carly’s durability test isn’t easy to pass; however, Bullymake delivers. If your pup scored ‘Destroyer’ in the quiz, then this box is your match. This box is designed specifically for power chewers. Plus, you can choose a mix of toys and treats or opt for an all-toy box (which we do). Every toy is built like it has something to prove—and somehow, it usually does.
Even Carly gets a run for her money.
And yes, she now gets excited about every box that hits the porch. Even my Amazon orders. But when it’s Bullymake? She knows. And it’s game on.
Savvy Dog Mom Tip: Built for the toughest chewers, Bullymake toys won’t back down—and neither will your pup. Plans start at $39 per month.
Final Woof
Your dog’s personality isn’t just adorable—it’s the key to making every day with them more joyful, fun, and tailored to their needs. Choosing a subscription box that matches their vibe makes them happy—and it saves you from impulse-buying at the pet store and brings the fun straight to your doorstep.
Still not sure? Try thinking of your dog as a type:
- The Jock (Super Chewer or Bullymake)
- The Gourmet (Farmer’s Dog/Ollie)
- The Professor (PupBox)
- The Influencer (Dapper Dog)
- The Empath (RescueBox)
Whichever tail they wag, there’s a box that fits—and watching them light up every month when it arrives? That’s the part I’ll never get tired of.
(Carly’s pick? Bullymake, paws down.)
Take the Dog Subscription Box Quiz
🎯 Find out which box your pup will love most—take this fun (and fast!) quiz.
Not all pups are the same—and not all subscription boxes should be either. Answer a few fun questions, and we’ll match your dog with the perfect monthly surprise!
❓ 1. What’s your dog’s play style?
- A) Full-body toy takedowns and intense chewing
- B) Chasing, fetching, or tugging nonstop
- C) Solving puzzles, sniffing things out
- D) Dressing up and posing like a pro
- E) Exploring trails, beaches, and parks
- F) Relaxing in their safe spot, cuddling close
❓ 2: What’s their reaction to a delivery box?
- A) Tears into it like it wronged them
- B) Bounces around and demands it now
- C) Sniffs everything with deep concentration
- D) Sits like royalty waiting to be served
- E) Tries to carry it outside
- F) Waits politely but gets very wiggly
❓ 3: What’s their ideal weekend plan?
- A) Chew session + nap
- B) Backyard games + fetch
- C) Training, enrichment games, nose work
- D) Photoshoot and treat sampling
- E) Hiking, swimming, or car rides
- F) Cozy couch time with their favorite person
❓ 4: Pick the most “them” phrase:
- A) “No toy survives me.”
- B) “Play first. Ask questions later.”
- C) “Mental stimulation, please.”
- D) “But does this bowtie come in teal?”
- E) “Let’s go somewhere wild.”
- F) “As long as I’m with you, I’m good.”
❓ 5: What‘s their biggest quirk?
- A) They eat toys for breakfast
- B) They can’t sit still for more than 3 seconds
- C) They unlock puzzles faster than you
- D) They love attention (and the camera)
- E) They cry when you put away the leash
- F) They flinch at loud noises or sudden changes
❓ 6: Which best describes you?
- A) Always on the hunt for indestructible toys
- B) Constantly tossing tennis balls
- C) Trying to outsmart your dog
- D) Matching your pup’s bandana to your outfit
- E) Scheduling your trips around dog-friendly spots
- F) Looking for products that comfort, not overstimulate
RESULTS:
- Mostly A’s → The Toy Destroyer → Super Chewer or Bullymake
- Mostly B’s → The Energizer Pup → Chewy
- Mostly C’s → The Brainiac → PupBox
- Mostly D’s → The Glam Pup → Dapper Dog Box
- Mostly E’s → The Adventure Hound → Wild One Kit
- Mostly F’s → The Sensitive Soul → RescueBox
